The Lost Conversation


By Winslow Myers


Eight days of rafting down the Colorado River in the Grand Canyon with my daughter promised to be an exceptional experience. Introducing myself to a fellow voyager, a Texan, I joked that surely Texas wasn’t really planning to secede, because it would be a pain to have to obtain a visa to visit Austin. This didn’t seem to go over very well. Perhaps I had overreached. I retreated for the rest of the trip into an affable neutrality.

Turns out others did the same. There would be an occasional dig at Biden’s senility, or a whisper about Trump’s criminality, but soon a taboo began to govern the otherwise warm and caring sociability of our group. Even though we were a diverse assembly of 30 people, gay and straight, black and white, aged 9 to 81, a freewheeling dialogue about politics or religion in the group at large was strictly off the conversational table. In spite of us all being citizens of one country floating down wild rapids together in our country’s most magnificent national park, on a deeper level we remained as alienated as groundhogs and gardeners.

And that was fair enough as far as it went: people had paid for a challenging outdoor adventure, not a seminar on current events or conflicting epistemologies. Both of which continued to unfold at top speed without us. While we were without internet in the Canyon, Roe was overturned, and the poised young assistant to Mark Meadows tied the ex-President ever closer to the planning of the January 6th insurrection.

Progressives opened political conversations among themselves and no doubt conservatives did also. But because I find loyalty to the ex-President or to gun rights so mysterious, as a progressive I would have welcomed some sort of dialogue with opposing views, though we all sensed it was a bridge too far.

What we did have in common was the experience of the river and the canyon. Sleeping outside in the dry 90 degree heat at night, we shared the closeness of the stars ringed by looming black towers of stone, stars that included a spiral arm of the Milky Way, a faint mist of light that feathered across the more familiar constellations.

One of our participants was heard to assert that creation began 6000 years ago. During a hike up a small side-canyon, our guides pointed out a visible manifestation of the Great Unconformity, where quartz-like crystals rested directly on schist, indicating a geological gap, an erosion of evidence of a billion and a half years of change. My daughter, a trained biologist, was over the moon to have found a small rock with fossil ancestors of sea stars compressed into it before there was even a canyon at all but only layers of sediment spread out under a vast shallow sea.

The scientific evidence of a 13.85 billion-year unfolding from matter to cellular life to mammals with a capacity to care for their offspring seems to erase a lot of unnecessary conflict between science and religion—again a rich possible theme for a dialogue that never was. The factions in our group seemed fatally inhibited, perceiving each other as an immovable “they.”

Still, there were unmistakable “we” experiences. Midway down the river came one that topped even the raft-swallowing green rapids and the mile-high stepped cliffs glowing in the morning sunlight. We had stopped at yet another dry side-channel. After a short hike up through narrowing walls of smooth stone, with no advance warning, we came upon a string quartet playing Elgar! Waterproofing their instruments, the musicians had arrived safely by raft to concertize in this most wildly improbable of venues.

The music drew us into the larger conversation of the universe with itself: an enigmatically self-organizing system had crushed and melted and swirled titanic masses of rock, which over hundreds of millions of years sank below and rose again above great seas, leaching out elements that combined into the first forms of cellular life—life that became self-sentient and sawed down other woody forms of life to fashion cellos to play notes derived from harmonies already built into the cosmos, harmonies drawn forth into distinct combinations by the mind of Bach or Elgar, now conveyed to insect-bitten, sweaty river voyagers by these generous performers.

Call this unfolding creative process God or Evolution or what you will, we were in it together, regardless of the lack of a conversation that might have led to some affirmation of our group’s interdependence as citizens of one country, or at least as humans on one planet. Secession from the universe is not an option—even for Texas.

Winslow Myers, author of “Living Beyond War: A Citizen’s Guide,” serves on the Advisory Board of the War Preventive Initiative.

More Resources


11/20/2024
What Donald Trump's Revenge Agenda Is Hiding
Look past the flashy and controversial Cabinet nominees to find that Project 2025 is already being implemented

more info


11/20/2024
Make Education Great Again!
Imagine these words as the first speech delivered by the incoming Secretary of Education.Today, I am here to deliver bitter medicine: American education has failed. Teachers and parents, administrato

more info


11/20/2024
Time-Honored Tradition of Blaming the Left for Dem Defeats
This argument is particularly unconvincing this time around. And it doesn't offer a realistic prescription for future success.

more info


11/20/2024
Dems Are Going To Get Younger and More Radical


more info


11/20/2024
The Blurred Line Between X and the Trump Administration
Forget the ridiculous

more info


11/20/2024
DOGE Is a Great Idea. Trump Should Make It Permanent
DOGE represents a harbinger of deregulation for an incoming Trump administration, especially with Dogecoin enthusiast Elon Musk and Vivek Ramaswamy at the helm.

more info


11/20/2024
The DOGE Plan To Reform Government
Following the Supreme Court's guidance, we'll reverse a decadeslong executive power grab.

more info


11/20/2024
Could Trump Actually Get Rid of the Department of Education?
Getting rid of the agency would cause a lot of harm and wouldn't really change school curriculum.

more info


11/20/2024
How Dems Are Losing Tomorrow's Elections Today
America is outgrowing the Democratic Party.

more info


11/20/2024
Can a Fractured Democratic Party Learn the Lessons of 2024?
After a bruising campaign season and a humiliating defeat at the polls, this week saw Dems' internal conflicts spilling out into public view. Party insiders are now engaged in tit-for-tat Twitter battles that do nothing to offer the party a roadmap back to political contender status. Instead, they confirm normies' worst caricatures of Democratic dysfunction.

more info


11/20/2024
Pennsylvania Voters to Sen. Casey: 'It's Over, Bob'
Columnist David Marcus talks to voters in Bucks County and finds Democrats and Republicans agree that Sen. Bob Casey's refusal to concede is a bad look.

more info


11/20/2024
NC Republicans' Shameless New Power Grab
North Carolina voters spoke loud and clear two weeks ago when they elected Democrats to some of the most prominent statewide offices.

more info


11/20/2024
Trump Can and Should Fire Jerome Powell
Legacy media have been obsessing over whether President-elect Donald Trump can remove Jerome Powell, chairman of the Federal Reserve (the Fed). Jerome Powell recently came out and stated he would serve out his term - which ends in 2026. Further, Chairman Powell claims any attempt by President Trump to remove him is not "permitted under the law." Unfortunately for Chairman Powell, President-elect Trump can remove him - and he should - to make the federal bureaucracy respond to democratic pressures once again.

more info


11/20/2024
SecDef Austin: Women in Military Make U.S. Stronger
Austin in an exclusive interview with NBC News called women in the military a strong asset. Trump's choice for Secretary of Defense has cast doubt on women in combat roles.

more info


11/20/2024
Drone, Missile Defense Top Priorities for Next Defense Secretary
Pete Hegseth faces critical challenges in addressing U.S. vulnerabilities to advanced missile and drone threats as global tensions rise.

more info



Custom Search

More Politics Articles:

Related Articles

Environmentalists Should Get Behind Cleaner Fossil Fuels
Not all fossil fuels are created equally -- at least with respect to their carbon footprint.
Bill O'Reilly's Alleged Escapades, Hmmm
Bill O'Reilly most likely can afford to retire and he probably should be thinking about it before he spends all of his life savings on settling sexual harassment lawsuits. At least $13 million have been paid so far that we know about.
Hooray For Less Taxes! We Hope
Americans pay too much in taxes. President Trump's idea to eliminate four of the seven tax brackets is an excellent idea. Most Americans are sick and tired of paying everything they make in taxes. If you enjoy paying taxes and disagree with what I am writing simply write the Internal Revenue Service a check every month and mail them more money.
We won't rest until the American Health Care Act is law
Dan Weber, president of the Association of Mature American Citizens, warns that "liberals in Congress will continue to sabotage efforts to repeal and replace Obamacare. They see President Obama's so-called Affordable Care Act as a first step toward a single-payer system which is, itself, a first step toward the creation of a socialist state here in the U.S."
Middlemen Are Not Passing On All Drug Discounts Intended for Patients
Over 400,000 Americans with cancer suffer from a second disease -- "financial toxicity." The symptoms include missed mortgage and rent payments, raided retirement accounts, and decisions about whether to take medicines as prescribed or ration them to save money. Such choices can be deadly.
Supremes hand down big wins for the nation, says AMAC
The Supreme Court handed down "two big wins" for the American people this week, according to Dan Weber, president of the Association of Mature American Citizens.
Cut FDA Red Tape So Doctors Can Better Treat Patients
Doctors often fail to treat their patients with the most effective medicines -- but it's not their fault. Is an outdated FDA regulation to blame?
John McCain, Obamacare and Call 911 To Be Murdered
A Minnesota police office murdered Justin Damond this past week. According to reports she called 911 to report a possible sexual assault nearby her apartment where she lived. According to reports two police officers arrived after she called for help a second time. One of the police officers riding in the passenger side of the police car was reported to have been spooked and shot past the driving police officer and killed the woman approaching the car in her pajamas.
This is the End for Offshore Obstructionism
The Trump administration is one step closer to unlocking America's vast offshore energy reserves.
Surviving Nuclear Attack
President Donald Trump has vowed to meet more North Korea threats with "power the likes of which the world has never seen" and Kim Jong-un has responded with a plan for a nuke attack on the US island of Guam. Plans are being made for a horror scenario we must take seriously.
Forgotten conservative: Remembering George Schuyler
It was 40 years ago, August 31, 1977, that George Schuyler died. He has been largely forgotten, and that's a shame. At one point, Schuyler was one of the most recognized and read columnists in America, particularly from his platform at one of America's great African-American newspapers-the Pittsburgh Courier. He was also one of the nation's top conservative voices.
Liberalism - A Mark Too Low A Price Too High
The Senate recently confirmed two new appointees to the Federal Energy Regulatory Commission, or FERC, ending a seven-month dormancy due to lack of a quorum. With three members, two Republicans and one Democrat, one pick from each party remains for a full five-member commission.
America's Pain - Tomorrow You?
Northern California is suffering with some of the worse fires in that state's history. Twenty-three people have been reportedly killed with at least 285 people reported missing.
Expand the Health Savings Account 'Safe Harbor' To Reduce Healthcare Costs
As the health reform debate continues, partisans in both parties should adhere to a simple, overarching principle: help people who were hurt by Obamacare, but don't hurt those who were helped by the law.
On Sunday - Storm the Gates of Hell
.."On this rock I will build my church and the gates of hell will not overcome it," Matthew 16:18
After Sutherland Springs Church Massacre, Anglican Bishop Considers Arming Himself at the Altar
A man of the cloth in Pennsylvania who also wears a badge is now contemplating packing a pistol in the pulpit to protect his parish.
Remembering Fidel Castro's Death
This past week marked the anniversary of the death of Fidel Castro, our hemisphere's worst dictator for a half century. When we remember Castro's death, we should remember him for just that: death.
Energy Lessons from the Recent Hurricanes
Hurricanes Harvey and Irma killed dozens of Americans and caused tens of billions of dollars in property damage. But there's one silver lining. The storms taught us three invaluable lessons about the U.S. energy market.
To Curb Climate Change, Cities Need the Right Design
Over 300 mayors recently promised to uphold the goals of the Paris Climate Agreement. This pledge proves that cities are leading America's fight against climate change.
The Hypocrisy of Political Correctness
A professor at NYU was shunned by his colleagues because of "the content and structure of his thinking." That's right, the "thought police" were after him. They didn't like the fact that he was using social media to expose the hypocrisy of political correctness on campus.