Performance Appraisal for HR Professionals


By Sanjeev Himachali


Performance Appraisal for HR Professionals

Introduction and Purpose

Today, on 12th Nov. 2006 as I am sitting in my study-room, a thought just passed through my mind. The thought was that what will happen:

1. If the HR Team is evaluated by the employees of the company (Read: Appraised by those who are directly getting affected by their work?)?

2. If the employees are asked to decide the "percentage increment" and "promotions" for HR Staff?

3. If at the time of appraisal, employees are asked to decide as which HR person is professional and competent enough stay with the company and who need to be shown the exit-door? Or should be sent for training?

By doing so,

1. Will there be any change in the quality of work of HR Person?

2. Will there be any change is the attitude and behaviour of HR Person?

3. Will they be able to concentrate on actual work rather than bullying around?

In my opinion, I think it will help in changing not only the quality of work, attitude and behaviour but also the way in which most of the HR people work. Through out my career I have advocated that my appraisal has to be done by the employees …those who are directly affected by my performance (or non-performance) rather then going for Self-Appraisal or a Appraisal done by my boss (my superior).

Need for such system

1. Marketing department is appraised by revenue generated by them (Number of Unit Sold)

2. Production department is evaluated by number of units produced and the quality of each unit (Number of units returned)

3. Efficiency of a Customer Service Department can by known by the number of customers retained by them and number of customers lost.

4. IT professionals are judged by the number of projects handled by them, time they have taken to complete each module and of course the quality (which, is judged by clients)

5. The efficiency of a lawyer is known by the number of cases won by him.

6. The market value of a Movie Actor can be evaluated by number of hits or flops of his movies and revenue generated by each of his movie.

7. Players of any game are judged by number of matches won by them. (In India, success rate in the fiekd also decides the endorsement assignments for these players)

8. The efficiency of a teacher can be known by the number of students passed or failed in his or her subject.

9. Even politicians (whether they like or not) at least once in five years (in India) they are appraised by public and need to get elected by public votes.

So, how HR Department, which is a “Service Center” for “internal customer” (read as employees) can run away with just Self-Appraisal or one-to-one appraisal done by their bosses (or superiors)?

Readers may think that such practice of “appraisal by employees” is impossible or is difficult to administer. For some it might look funny. But, it is possible and not “so difficult” to handle.

Proposed Process and Step-by-step Path

To start with we can divide companies into following categories

1) Small Companies (with less than 500 employees)

2) Mid-Size Companies (more than 500 employees but less than 2000 employees)

3) Large size Companies (more than 2000 employees but less than 10,000 employees)

4) Mega-large Companies (more than 10,000 employees)

It is understood that all mid-size, large-size and mega-large companies are also multi-national, multi-location and multi-central organizations and each center or location they don’t have more than 500-700 employees. Ideally speaking each center is managed by one HR-Manager (Call by any name, HR-Head or General Manager or just Manager) along with a team of 5-7 HR personnel taking care of various functions of HR (HR-Operations, Employee Relations, Recruitment, Training and Development etc etc).

Step-1: Prepare an Appraisal form (or format or questionnaire) based on the role of the HR person handling particular function…listing the grades, evaluation criteria etc. It should clearly specify that people with so and so rating will get this much of increment and people above X rating will be considered for promotion.

Step-2: Take a random sample based on the size of the employee strength at that particular center. Ideally speaking there should be one representative for a group of 10 employees.

Step-3: Collect the filled appraisal forms. Tabulate the data and analyze the same by using simple statistical tools.

So, here you are, with the end result and this will decide as who will stay in the company and who will move out. Who need training? Who will get increment and promotions?

Involving more people in Appraisal Process

Not only employees but your team-members should also appraise you, because your performance (or non-performance) also affects the productivity of these functions. For example; the work done by HR-Operations team directly affects the work of Employee Relations Team; in a similar manner the data supplied by recruitment team affects the speed and efficiency of HR-Operations Team.

We can give different weightage for different “evaluation center” and it should we such that it should not dilute the actual purpose.

I propose that the weightage should be as follows:

1) Employees or Clients – 45%

2) Team Member or internal Customers – 25%

3) Self-Appraisal – 10%

4) Appraisal by boss – 20%

Explanation: If total marks are 10, employees can give you marks out-of 4.5; your team members can assign of marks out-of 2.5 and your boss…out of 2.

Evaluation Criteria (Just an Example)

Like our schools and colleges lets keep 35% as passing marks. So, anybody who is getting less than 3.5 on a scale of 1-10 need to be shown the “Exit Door”. Person whose score is between 3.6-5.5, need a lot of improvement in his work and hence need to given “Functional Training” and cannot be considered for Increment or promotion. Anybody who scores between 5.6 – 8.0 can be given increment from 1% - 50% of their salary. Only those whose score is more than 8 should be considered for promotions.

Conclusion

Such system can bring transparency in the system.

1. It will remove the “favoritism” or “buttering” practice from the system.

2. It will increase the “team-spirit” and “team cohesiveness”.

3. It will increase the “need to learn” and update themselves.

4. It will also increase the quality of work.

5. And last but not least, it will take out (change the psychology of) some HR people from the position, where they consider themselves as GOD and think that they can “make or break” the career (or in large sense, the life) of anybody.

I know that many HR personnel don’t like to have such system. That is the reason why processes like “Balance Score Card” or “360-Degree Appraisal System” has not been implemented by most of the HR-Departments and are just used for study purpose. I understand that majority of HR-Personnel’s are not even aware of various HR-Metrics, which are applicable on HR department.

These are my views and it will be nice to have your comments and feedback on the same. What do you think?

Awaiting your comments and feedback

Regards

Sanjeev Himachali

E-mail: ss_himachali@yahoo.com; sanjeev.himachali@gmail.com

Blog: http://sanjeevhimachali.blogspot.com


More Resources

Unable to open RSS Feed $XMLfilename with error HTTP ERROR: 404, exiting

More Management Information:

Related Articles


Dont Sweat the Small Stuff with Your Credit Policy
Do you know how many customers you have that are past due right now? How many bad checks are sitting on your desk that you don't know what to do with? How many dunning letters do you send out a month?How would you like to answer those questions with none, or very few? In a new book, "Become the Squeaky Wheel," Michelle Dunn, explains and outlines some easy procedures you can use to erase bad debt, and prevent it in the future."One thing that is often overlooked is how to prevent future credit issues," says Michelle Dunn.
Innovation Management - Diversity Can Make All The Difference
Companies are welcoming a diverse range of employees (The Sunday Times, April 10 2005). Doh!It is incredible that this concept is getting coverage in 2005.
The Higher You Go
The higher you go, the cooler it becomes. Really? Let us begin from first principles.
Effective Multi Cultural International Business Meetings
Of the many areas in international business where cultural differences manifest is in the corporate meeting room. International meetings are an area where differences in cultural values, etiquette, interpretations of professional conduct and corporate rules are at their most visible and challenging to control.
How Can A Communications Audit Help You?
Organizations communicate in two directions: internally to staff and externally to clients, customers, shareholders, stakeholders, the media. Faulty internal communications can lead to mistakes, discouraged and unhappy staff, employees leaving the company.
Why Businesses Need to Start Nurturing Collective Wisdom
COLLECTIVE WISDOM CAN BE AN effective tool for solving the problem of knowledge deficit, or the underutilization of organizational knowledge. If you are a small, medium or large business, and you don't have a method in place for harnessing and managing your organization's collective knowledge, you may be losing opportunities for significant revenue enhancement.
Management to the Vision-Contribution and the Role of Compliance
As a manager our role is to:1. Establish the vision, or our contribution to the vision.
Performance Appraisal Checklist: Raise Not Just Appraise Performance
It's that time again! Perhaps the most dreaded management practice is the annual performance review. Whenever the subject comes up, out comes the groans from both managers and staff no matter what industry or type of company.
Performance Expectations - 5 Tips and 5 Questions
People want to understand their role - they want to do well! So by being clear, really clear about what it expected of them, makes a big, big difference! And that improves performance as well as saving you time chasing others around to deliver what you want.5 TipsBe Clear - your people need to know what they are doing, both in terms of actions and the standards that you will be expecting.
Business Innovation - Value versus Quality
Creativity can be defined as problem identification and idea generation whilst innovation can be defined as idea selection, development and commercialisation.There are other useful definitions in this field, for example, creativity can be defined as consisting of a number of ideas, a number of diverse ideas and a number of novel ideas.
How to get an Audiences Attention
A trainer dryly discussing how to motivate people in an organization basically has just another "point-by-point" presentation. But suppose that he mounts the podium and begins to speak.
Manage Communication to Add Value
Management guru Tom Peters says white collar workers and managers in functional departments need to protect their futures.They have to learn "the difference between doing totally acceptable work and creating very new value.
Keys to Feeling Powerfull In An Uncertain World
Life has always been full of uncertainties. Over the last several years with downsizing, bankruptcies, scandals, crime, the economic environment, and the threat of war, people are feeling power-less, fearful, and stressed about their present and future lives.
Introducing the 15 Frameworks of Successful Self-Employed Professionals
A framework is a way of thinking, a point-of-view, a perspective on something. Here are the 15 frameworks of the successfully self-employed professional.
Operating on Perpetual Overload?
Check Out Your E-HabitsAnother week has ended. And, despite moving at the speed of light, you've once again barely made a dent in your more important goals or projects.
Keeping and Motivating the Best Employees
Keeping and Motivating the Best EmployeesIn "You Win With People" we talked about the need to hire the very best people to build your team. Now that you've done that the question becomes, how do you keep them, and how do you keep them motivated.
Identifying Candidates for Leadership
A critical task in the succession planning process of any organization is identifying candidates. Traditionally, candidates have been identified based on past performance.
How To Write Commercial Collections Letters
It is sometimes valuable to bring the sales manager into this step of the collection process. Information concerning the delinquency can often be obtained from the sales department.
Real Costs in Distribution and What it Means To Your Company
Ever feel that all the lawyers in thh Country need to give their lives up for our freedom, by exiting the planet forthwith? Yes, me too. In an article in CCJ-Commercial Carrier Journal entitled "Ticking Away" The Insurance Time Bomb.
Blame Culture Blues - How the Language of Blame Manifests Organisational Underperformance
If you have ever worked within a large organisation then you are sure to have heard the term 'we will not have a blame culture' at some point. However the sheer fact that this statement can be made is an indication that a blame culture already exists.